I wasn't sure I would like this book, because I'd been mostly watching YouTube videos on zero waste, and felt that many "zero-wasters" came across as pompous know-it-alls who have "arrived" and who just want to be paraded around and have people admire them – rather than being humble mentors.

Bea Johnson's book proved that Bea, at least, isn't like that. She grew up in France, living a modest lifestyle, then moved to America as an adult and took on the "American dream" lifestyle. After living this way for awhile, she started to realize the troubles it brought and moved toward zero-waste. I love that she recognizes that zero-waste is a goal, but it will never happen for any of us (there will always be a certain amount of waste) and the things that each of us compromise on will be different.

She says toward the end of the book, "Some said that our household doesn't do enough because we are carnivores and travel to France, for example. Others said that we do too much, that our lifestyle is unrealistic or extreme. How is it unrealistic if I am living it?" -p. 253

The book itself is incredibly thorough. There are only illustrations on the chapter intro pages, and the rest is pure text (apart from a few illustrations to help explain various processes she describes, such as papermaking). There were so many questions that have popped into my head during my online exploration of zero waste, and she answers nearly all of them. The resources section is also full of truly practical resources.

My biggest beef with the book is her section on kids. She claims (as do many zero-wasters) that overpopulation is the cause of a failing environment (without citing any real facts), and suggests we all reconsider having large families, even suggesting that we adopt, instead. I'm a huge advocate for adoption, but it's certainly not rooted in environmentalism! (That's not a good enough reason to adopt – adoption should be about a child joining a family, rather than seen as a means to make one feel better about his ecological footprint.) She also talks about "protecting ourselves from surprise pregnancies" and includes Planned Parenthood as a resource. (I definitely can't get behind that organization!)

At the end of the day, I strongly believe that over-consumption and incorrect-consumption (that is, using plastic and synthetics instead of natural materials that can be returned to the earth) is the problem. If the entire global population began living, overnight, with a desire to redeem the earth and care for it, many of our "waste" issues would be a thing of the past.

Anyway, that chapter is what bumped my rating from 5 stars to 4. I would definitely still recommend it as a very comprehensive read for anyone interested in going plastic-free, or just in implementing a few resource-saving habits into their regular lifestyle. ( )

Very inspiring. Bea shares some of her meal plans, recipes, formulas and other tips. She has a map on her website for bulk grocers; it's mostly whole foods, but not exclusively. ( )

Disappointing. It focused mainly on products, not home systems.

Tried again to like it on audio. Oddly though, the author, in the first page or so, describes her childhood in Provence, the narrator chosen has a clipped British accent. I might have listened a tad more if the accent was French. Downgrading my rating for such stupidity. ( )

I liked this book for what it was but I don't feel like it's necessary for someone who wants to reduce waste. In that case just go on her blog. This book consisted of lists and ideas that weren't really fully fleshed out. This book was more like a compilation of her most popular blog posts. Though she explained how she got to the process she uses for whatever routine in her house she doesn't totally cover the benefits. She lays them out like a check list of sorts: reduced cost, less time spent, less exposure to plastics. Yeah but at least explain these benefits. She did mention her husband crunching numbers and confirming they were spending less but nothing much about the other stuff.

I wouldn't suggest purchasing the book unless you want the check lists in one easy to find place. ( )

I read the author's blog and find that she constantly challenges my thinking regarding waste. Is she extreme? Yes. Oh yes. And she knows it and admits it, declaring that she sees herself as the experimenter in order to save everyone else the time of figuring it out. So I was pre-disposed to be interested in this book. And...no. Just no. She's a blogger, not a writer or researcher, and it shows. There was a lot more that could have been done here in terms of making the waste reduction argument and setting the call to action and she missed it all in favor of forced alphabetized lists of tips.

But I will say...after years of fruitlessly trying to get my husband interested in reducing our waste, I simply left the book lying around the living room for a few days and...presto! He's remembering to bring the reusable grocery bags and thinking about what we buy at the store. So it serves that purpose. Otherwise? Just read the blog. ( )

Many asides in this review of a book I wanted to like but felt patronised by.

I did want to like this book and there are some great points in the book (must start knitting that stuffed rug and use my dryer lint in it, if I do enough to use up the lint every time I clean it out that would be a great mark of progress... sorry, an aside that occured to me as I read), but I also felt that she really wasn't living in a world I could as easily.

I'm coeliac (well technically I'm severely gluten intolerant but that sounds faddish, trust me the two-day stomach cramps aren't from my mind) and buying from open bins isn't an option for me, that way cross-contamination and sick lies. It would be the same for most folks with allergies. While it would be nice to live like she does there are also problems with it and I don't think some of her ideas are realistic. I have plans for my clothing and for my wardrove over the next few years and some of them involve slowly wearing more of it, getting rid of the excess and only replacing what I have to (which I expect to be mostly trousers and shoes, knitting my own socks is a for granted moment)

I don't think it's practical and non-wasteful to empty your wardrobe/closet/whatever of clothes you wear, I think it's a better plan to work on methods of storage that ensure roatation and removing those things that don't suit you and passing them on and removing the things that are in bad condition and finding ways of disposing of them that's environmentally sound.

I think that rethinking how we use things and how we dispose of things is a good thing. I honestly would find her a hard friend, sounds like she is an evangelist of her lifestyle to a degree that I would find painful. Good luck to her, she did make me think about some things in my life that need change but I don't think that they would suit everyone.

I found the Happiness Project more inspirational. ( )