Page images
PDF
EPUB

In the two laft lines, there is a happy and noble combination of imagery and fentiment.

But the next chorus affords a beauty of the fofter kind, where the poet thus feelingly defcribes the delights of connubial love.

"Oh fource of ev'ry focial tye, "United wish, and mutual joy! "What various joys on one attend, "As fon, as father, brother, hufband, friend? "Whether his hoary fire he fpies, "While thousand grateful thoughts arife; "Or meets his fpoufe's fonder eye; "Or views his fmiling progeny; "What tender paffions take their turns, "What home-felt raptures move? "His heart now melts, now leaps, now burns, "With rev'rence, hope, and love."

A mind endued with the leaft fenfibility, cannot fail of being affected by the delicacy and tendernefs of these fentiments, as well as charmed by the force and propriety of the epithets, and the elegance and harmony of the numbers.

The next piece which falls under confideration, is the Effay on Criticism, which, extraordinary as it may feem, was written before our poet had attained his twentieth year; and published within two years afterwards, being as fhort a time as he ever fuffered any thing to lie by him.

It had not probably been published fo foon, but for the importunity of his old friend Sir William Trumball, to whom he fent a copy of it, and who

was

was fo charmed with it, that, in a letter which he addreffed to him in return, he concludes thus, "All I can add is, that if your excefs of modefty "fhould hinder you from publishing this effay, "I fhall only be forry I have no more credit with you, to perfuade you to oblige the public, and "in particular, Dear Sir, &c.

[ocr errors]

This poem, the writer of the effay candidly allows to be a master-piece of its kind, and that notwithstanding the partial commendation of Mr. Addison, who remarks that "the obfervations "follow one another, like thofe of Horace's Art "of poetry*, without that methodical regularity, "which would have been neceffary in a profe "writer," yet it is evident that the plan is regu lar, and the conduct of it masterly.

Indeed, it is difficult, as our poet's learned friend and commentator obferves, to conceive any prerogative in verfe, to difpenfe with method and regularity. Befides, in truth, our poet laid the plan, and digefted all the matter in profe; and then, as he has been heard to fay, he turned it into verfe with great rapidity.

The general order and design of this work is fully delineated in the admirable commentary fubjoined to it. But it would not be confiftent with the profeffed plan of this hiftory, fhould I omit to point out its moft diftinguished beauties and defects, which cannot be done, without giving a fhort analysis of the poet's chain of argument:

* That Horace attended to method in his Art of Poetry, has been fhewn by a learned critic. See Mr. Hurd's comment on the Epiftle to the Pifos.

F 2

and

and I cannot help thinking it a capital objection to the essay above-mentioned on Mr. POPE's writings, &c. that the effayift frequently only felects detached paffages, as the foundation of his encomium or cenfure, without attempting to connect the fenfe. Unless we recollect the writer's general scope of reafoning, we cannot always fully relish the beauties of particular parts, more efpecially in Mr. POPE, who has the particular skill to employ poetical ornament in aid of his arguments. Add to this, that when parts are thus taken detached, we may fometimes impute faults to the writer, which are fo only from the partial view we have given of his work *.

The poem confifts of one book, which is divided into three principal parts, or members. The first of them giving rules for the study of the art of criticism; the fecond expofing the caufes of wrong judgment; and the third, marking out the morals of the critic.

Though this piece is intitled fimply an Effay on Criticifm, yet it contains feveral precepts, equally relative to the good writing, as to the true judging of a poem; which is fo far from violating the unity of the subject, that it preferves and compleats it.

To this effect, fays our Poet, in the following lines:

"The critic eye, that microscope of wit,
"Sees hairs and pores, examines bit by bit:
"How parts relate to parts, or they to whole,
"The body's harmony, the beaming foul,

"Are things which Kufter, Burman, Waffe fhall see, "When man's whole frame is obvious to a flea."

The

The poet having in the opening, fhewn the use and feasonablenefs of the fubject, he proceeds to inquire into the proper qualities of a true critic.

""Tis with our judgments as our watches, none "Go juft alike, yet each believes his own. "In Poets, as true genius is but rare,

True taste as feldom is the Critic's fhare; "Both muft alike from Heav'n derive their light, "These born to judge, as well as those to write."

The reasoning in these lines, as the learned commentator obferves, is conclufive; and the fimilitude extremely just.

It may be neceffary, however, to confider this paffage refpecting the human faculties, somewhat more critically; as it will be of use hereafter, in the attempt to afcertain the nature and extent of our author's genius.

It has been faid that "judgment, when it goes "alone, is generally regulated, or at leaft much "influenced, by cuftom, fashion or habit;, and "never certain and conftant, but when founded upon TASTE; which is the fame in the critic, as GENIUS in the poet. That, in fact, genius " and taste are but one and the fame faculty differently exerting itself under different names, "in the two profeffions of poetry and criticism: "for that the art of poetry confifts in felecting "out of all thofe images which prefent them"felves to the fancy, fuch of them as are truly "beautiful: And the art of criticifm in difcerning, "and fully relishing, what it finds fo felected."

[blocks in formation]

Though it may be allowed, that judgment is never certain, but when ripened into tafte: nevertheless we must be cautious how we fall into an error, which has been adopted by many writers, who have confidered judgment and tafte as things totally diftin&t: for they appear to be the fame faculty, and to differ only in the degree and extent of their application. Tafte is nothing but judgment matured and refined. The faculty of judgment, is born with us; tafte is, in a great measure, acquired. Judgment, is the faculty of comparing and feparating our ideas: tafte, is the fame faculty of comparison improved, and applied to works of imagination and elegance.

The man of tafte feems at one glance, by a kind of intuition, to difcern what is beautiful and elegant; and this has mifled many to imagine that taste is a faculty diftinct from judgment. But, in truth, we cannot discover what is beautiful, but by comparison: and to compare, as has been faid, is the office of judgment. Tafte, therefore, is the refult of repeated, tho' perhaps imperceptible operations of the judgment, by which, we at length acquire that quick difcernment of, and habitual relish for, the beautiful.

The excellence of tafte, depends on an extenfive knowledge in the fubjects of the fine arts; and on that habit of comparifon, which alone can enable us to discern and relish what is truly beautiful. For inftance, fhould a man of good natural judgment who had never seen a picture, behold two portraits of the human figure, daubed upon a fign, of which the one was manifeftly a better imitation of nature than the

other,

« PreviousContinue »