Page images
PDF
EPUB
[ocr errors]
[ocr errors]

discovered in the ruins of private dwellings may be mentioned an unfinished kneeling figure holding a tablet, and measuring seventeen inches in height. It is described by Mr. Petrie as "blocked out in the rough, and affording a good example of artists' work-one arm having the flat side of the block left, showing the canon-squares. A terra-cotta statuette of an infant deity riding on a goose, of which Mr. Petrie has sent a photograph, is a peculiarly beautiful specimen of a well-known type, variously identified with Harpocrates, Eros, and Bacchus. The composition is almost identical with a terra-cotta of Tarsus in the Louvre (see fig. 5, plate 53, of Heuzey's Figurines antiques); but the modelling is far finer than the Louvre specimen, and the adjuncts are

escalier et un couloir qui n'avaient jamais jusqu'alors été parfaitement dégagés. M. Sayce y a copié, cette année, une trentaine au moins de graffiti phéniciens inédits et dont vous avez dû recevoir communication. Je regrette de n'avoir eu cette idée que l'an dernier; sans cela ces textes dans le Recueil des inscriptions sémitiques de auraient pu vous arriver à temps pour figurer l'Académie. Dans ce couloir, il y a aussi beaucoup de graffiti cariens et chypriotes sans compter les grecs. Ma campagne s'est fort bien terminée à Saqqarah par la découverte d'une tombe intacte de la 6e dynastie. Nous y avons trouvé cinq barques funéraires avec tout leur équipage, un grand cercueil en bois couvert d'inscriptions, des colliers, des vases, un grand sarcophage en calcaire encore fermé que je vais ouvrir demain. C'est la première tombe intacte et aussi ancienne trouvée position des objets est la même que dans les tombes thébaines. Les textes du cercueil en bois prouvent que le rituel funéraire était déjà en usage dès la 6o dynastie. Je crois qu'en certaines parties, il remonte aux temps antehistoriques et qu'il existait avant Ménès.

fasten the necklace at the back of her neck,
or to take her hand in the way of kindness,
or in any other. But gradually, as the mean-
ness of the foolish little Duke becomes more
apparent and more odious to her, and as the
otherwise cold, she takes to her husband very
embers of that silly love burn out on a hearth
much. Other people have seen how good are
his qualities, and the lady, who is not lacking
in intelligence by any means, likewise beholds
that they are estimable. Furthermore, he
withholds his love from her, so that she begins
A little later on she wants it
to want it.
very much, but he has not a friendly word
for her. Just as the model young woman had

more artistically rendered. The child bears in par un Européen. J'ai pu constater que la dis- done an atrocious wrong, the model young

his left hand a torch of Eros, and puts the first finger of his right hand to his mouth, in token of infancy. On his head he wears a cumbrous wreath surmounted by the emblem of Horns. His attitude is that classified by M. Heuzey as "l'enfant assis sur une de ses jambes replié's.' AMELIA B. EDWARDS,

[ocr errors]

Hon. Sec. Egypt Exploration Fund.

THE next general meeting of the Hellenic Society will take place at 22 Albemarle Street

on Thursday, May 8, at 5 p.m. A paper will

be read by Mr. Theodore Bent on his recent journey among the Cyclades.

[ocr errors]

THE STAGE.

99 THE IRON-MASTER

NOTES ON ART AND ARCHAEOLOGY. MR. J. THEODORE BENT has returned to England from a visit of about six months to the Cyclades. During that time he explored almost every one of the islands, and has brought back a rich harvest of fresh matter, both archaeo-Georges logical and modern. He gave particular attention to the island of Antiparos, which has not been inhabited in recent times, but which he found to abound in prehistoric graves full of gquaint little images. FROM a

letter of Dr. Schliemann dated April 22, we learn that he was then at Athens, but hoping to return immediately to Tiryns, where his fellow-worker, Herr Dörpfeld, was continuing the excavations. It is his intention to publish the results of his latest and not least extraordinary discovery in a comparatively small volume, which, however, will be abundantly illustrated, not only with wood-cuts of the minor objects found, but with reproductions in facsimile of the marvellous wall-paintings of the palace. In these, four colours are used, besides white, but no shading. An interesting feature is a decorative pattern identical with that on the ceiling of the thalamos at Orchomenos in Boeotia which Dr. Schliemann brought to light last year.

AT THE ST. JAMES'S.

HOWEVER painful was the subject of M. Ohnet's drama "Le Maître de Forges"-which has been a success in Paris -it was not a theme that the Lord Chamberlain could taboo; and as it was set forth with a good deal of force, and gave opportunities for distinguished acting, it was almost inevitable that we should see the piece here. We have seen it, and did not enjoy it, yet the picce has strength and the acting is admirable. Mr. Pinero has been charged with the task of adapting it, and, save for a few queer instances of mis-translation, has adapted it well. The piece has its scenes of comedy; it has its scenes of intense drama. Its attractiveness, such as it is, consists, in London, in the acting of Mrs. Kendal. That in it which repels and revolts the spectator is in part the ugliness of the theme, in part the fact that a profound improbability is at the very base of the plot. We said a profound improbability; but no, there are two of them. The heroine, if she were the woman of gracious thought and considerate act that she is held forth to be, would never have married Ox Tuesday next, May 6, Messrs. Christie for the reason the playwright asserts. She will sell the engraved wood-blocks of Bewick-loved a foolish young Duke, who was, to boot, nearly fourteen hundred in number-that a relation. The Duke, being bad as well as remained in possession of his last surviving foolish, jilted her for a perfectly vulgar young daughter, Miss Isabella Bewick, who died last year at an advanced age. The include all the woman, the daughter of Moulinet, the maker illustrations and tail-pieces to the British Birds, of chocolate. She hid her distress from him; the Quadrupeds, Aesop's Fables, and Bewick's and, not content with letting concealment work havoc with the damask cheek, she straightway accepted the offer of marriage of an honest and excellent iron-master whom she had not before even listened to. Not caring twopence-halfpenny for him, the kind and gracious lady did him the injustice accept him. Further, she carried her protamme out-she actually married him in

THE new museum of archaeology at Cambridge is to be opened with some ceremony on Tuesday next, May 6, at 2.30 p.m.

Life of himself.

SOME while ago a committee was formed to collect subscriptions for a bronze statue of Berlioz at Paris. One of the last acts of the now defunct Municipal Council was to authorise its erection in the middle of the square Vintimille, out of which runs the rue de Calais where the composer died.

[ocr errors]

IN a letter to M. Renan, thanking him fospite. That is improbability the first. the subscription opened on behalf of Egyptian archaeology, M. Maspero writes:"Avec ces ressources, je ferai déblayer Louqsor et Je reporterai sur l'exploration de Saqqarah tout ce que le gouvernement égyptien me donnera d'argent. En faisant l'année dernière nettoyer le temple d'Abydos, j'ai mis au jour un

Médinet Habou.

Hating him so much that she must needs shiver if he performed the not very tender service of fastening a necklace at the back of her neck, or if he took her hand in friendliness or in the way of kindness, it is not to be wondered at that he shortly declined even to

man-but he is not a very young manbehaves scarcely less discreditably. Seeing plainly that she is repentant, and that there is no effort she will not make to appease him, he repels her cruelly. He will have nothing whatever to say to her. He is sullen and glum. That is improbability the second.

[ocr errors]

"The

Of course, if you can once allow that a couple of wholly estimable people would make these mistakes, the plot is strong, the play is a good one, you follow the story with faith, and not only with interest. But upon some people's credulity this makes too large a demand; and, as we are among them, we have to take refuge, for our part, in the acting of Mrs. Kendal. That is of course remarkable. Mrs. Kendal is always best, as, indeed a fine actress ought to be best, in a sympathetic part. As the heroine of "Diplomacy,' as the heroine of Squire," as the heroine of Mr. Clement Scott's little adaptation of "Jeanne qui pleure et Jeanne qui rit," Mrs. Kendal reaches her highest level. That is to say, she makes in these her greatest effect upon the audienceespecially upon simple people who are not eternally analysing-who are not always wanting to know how far this is clever, but rather how far it is pleasant. Well, unless these simple people-or these subtle people in their simpler moods, if you will-bring with them to the St. James's Theatre a vast provision of credulity, they will not find Mrs. Kendal's new part sympathetic; throughout its performance they will be harassed by the thought that this could never have been unless the woman was bad. We are not sure that the remarkable artist is herself quite free from that thought. But, like an advocate engaged on the wrong side, she works manfully, with vigour, with experience, with tact, with ingenuity, to conquer for a while the sympathies she can hardly look to hold permanently. The play leaves many blank spaces for the actress. with her wonderful and expressive pantomime. Granting her her one improbability, all else with Mrs. Kendal is probable. She reveals to you how it would be. Never has she been more skilful. And Mr. Kendal, made up excellently as the stolid French man of businessa man with neither the freedom of the upper class nor the uncontrolled excitability of the lower-Mr. Kendal seconds her well. He has got French gestures, French bourgeois passion. Miss Linda Dietz does not play the Baronne de Préfont much in the style of a Baronne. The accent of naturalness-that not learnt upon the theatre-seems to be wanting to her, but of ordinary theatrical resource she is sufficiently mistress. Miss Webster is really delightfully fresh as a pleasant young rela

She fills them all in

tion; and so is Mr. George Alexander as an ingenious stripling who desires to marry her. It is positively reinvigorating to see them. But neither they nor Mrs. Kendal's unapproached art and sympathetic presence can make the play either healthy or truc. So well is it acted, however, that we fancy for a long time it must fill the playhouse. FREDERICK WEDMORE.

MUSIC.

"THE CANTERBURY PILGRIMS" AT DRURY LANE.

[ocr errors]

MR. C. VILLIERS STANFORD is a fortunate man. His "Savonarola," produced at Hamburg on April 18, was received with every mark of success; and now, only ten days later (April 28), his Canterbury Pilgrims was welcomed at Drury Lane as heartily as was the "mery compagnie " which assembled at the "gentil hostelrie" the "Tabard just five hundred and one years ago-at least, so runs the fable. When the curtain rises we see Hubert, an apprentice, and his companions singing a madrigal beneath the window of Cicely, the fair daughter of Geoffrey, host of the famed "Tabard Inn." Hubert is informed that the maiden is about to start with the pilgrims bound for Canterbury, to be handed over to the safe keeping of a griffin aunt. The pilgrims, first heard behind the scenes, now enter in twos and threes: we see the Merchant "in mottelee," the Clerk with threadbare cloak, the Doctor, the ware and wise Serjeant, the Nun, the Monk, and others. They suddenly exchange their song of mourning for one of mirth, then fall back into their chant, and once again become merry. Now Sir Christopher Synge, a knight, has fallen in love with the " pretty queen Cicely, and Hal o' the Chepe, his faithful clerk, has formed a plan to carry her off when the pilgrims have reached Sidenbourne, the Travellers' Rest. There is plot and counterplot, but to try to describe the fun of the second act would occupy far too much space. The young lady has been confided to the care of Dame Margery, Sir Christopher's wife; and we have the old libertine, the young apprentice, the enraged father, and the offended wife, all busy making or marring schemes. The end of it is that Hubert runs off with Cicely; Sir Christopher returns home, his scheme having ignominiously failed; while Geoffrey, pursuing the lovers, takes Hubert prisoner. In the third act Hubert is brought before a Justice of the Peace, who is none other than Sir Christopher himself. He and his clerk Hal find both plaintiff and defendant troublesome persons; they try to get Hubert out of the way, but Dame Margery and Cicely appear at the most critical moment, and Sir Christopher, making the best of a bad job, reverses the sentence of imprisonment. So he thus pleases his wife, and the father forgives the lovers, who are supposed to marry and live happily ever afterwards.

A capital plot, and an exceedingly wellwritten libretto by Mr. Gilbert à Beckett, naturally led Mr. Stanford to do his best. Of the extreme cleverness of the music there can surely be no question. The composer and librettist have evidently taken "Die Meistersinger" as their model - and a very good model too. There are many features in the play and touches in the music which irresistibly recall Wagner's celebrated Opera, but "The Canterbury Pilgrims" is none the less enjoyable on that account. The most important thing to notice in the music is the extensive use made of representative themes. The composer has boldly adopted the German master's system. The marvellous use made by Wagner of Leitmotive has been acknowledged

even by those who disapprove of the method, less ability and individuality to work on the but it seemed dangerous for any composer of has been most successful, and those interested same lines. Now we think that Mr. Stanford in the future Opera cannot fail to watch with attention this bold and ingenious attempt. In all the acts there is no break in the music, but there are plenty of concerted pieces with both tune and form. The composer, while exhibiting great talent in his mode of dealing with the orchestra, shows, however, at times that he is bound to a system; there are moments of weakness, moments when we feel that we have the letter rather than the spirit. We speak not of the orchestration, which throughout is excellent, but of the style of writing. It does seem surprising to us that Mr. Stanford, seeing that he was writing a comic Opera, did not avail himself of spoken dialogue, which would have formed an agreeable contrast, and have proved, we fancy, in several situations highly effective. And then, again, while praising the work, we would not disguise the fact that the music often shows a certain lack of originality. Individuality is, after all, the pearl of great price, and clever writing and ingenious orchestration are not sufficient in themselves. We speak plainly, but, when we think of the music in the first scene of the second act, the serenade (omitted in performance), and parts of the love duet, we feel disposed to think that Mr. Stanford has a store of originality still latent. The comic scenes show that he has a keen sense of humour. In the first act the madrigal sung by the apprentices is set to the famous old English song "Sumer is i cumen in." The first bar forms a leading theme constantly heard during the Opera; and it gives a quaint and thoroughly English flavour to the work. The chorus of pilgrims is very pleasing; of other picces we would name (besides those already mentioned) the sextett in the first act, the "plot" trio, and the whole of the eighth scene in the second act; and the quintett in the last act.

The performance of the Opera was remarkably fine. Miss Clara Perry made a very good Cicely, and Miss Marian Burton was fairly successful as the Dame Marjery. Mr. Ludwig (Sir Christopher), Mr. Barrington Foote (Hal), and Mr. Davies (Hubert) all deserve special praise. The chorus sang well, and acted with unusual animation and attention to matters of detail. Mr. Augustus Harris may be congratulated on the manner in which the piece was put on the stage. The house was full, and the applause at the end of each act most enthusiastic. The Opera was conducted by the composer, and the reception given to "The Canterbury Pilgrims" was indeed a brilliant one."

J. S. SHEDLOCK.

RECENT CONCERTS. THE programme of the concert of the London Musical Society given last Saturday evening at St. James's Hall contained several novelties. First came a short Cantata for solo (Miss Amy Aylward) and chorus, "Oh, Weep for Those," by Ferdinand Hiller, a short and simple composition. Miss A. Zimmermann played Schumann's Concertstück in G (op. 92) with orchestra, an interesting though by no means an important work. Four Trios for female voices by Brahms, with accompaniment of harp and two horns, are quaint, but not particularly original; the second and fourth are decidedly the best numbers. The second part of the concert commenced with Jensen's Cantata, "The Feast of Adonis," scored for orchestra by J. Buttis, a work accurately described in the programmebook as "full of melody and cheerfulness." The solos were taken by Miss A. Aylward, Miss H. Weber, and Miss L. Little. And,

lastly, there was Schumann's Ballad, "The ton, and Herr von Zur-Mühlen), chorus, and King's Son," for solos (Miss Little, Mr. Brerepleasing writing in it, but, as a whole, it is a orchestra. There is some highly effective and laboured composition. Miss Zimmermann contributed solos by Chopin and Mr. C. H. Parry, The performances, generally speaking, were satisfactory; the quality of tone of the sopranos was, however, not very pleasing. Mr. Barnby conducted the whole of the concert in an efficient manner.

Dr. Hans von Bülow gave the first of two pianoforte recitals at St. James's Hall last Tuesday afternoon. The programme commenced with Brahms' interesting but difficult Sonata in F minor (op. 5). It was a treat to hear this work interpreted by an artist who is endowed with rare intellectual gifts, and who possesses complete command of the key-board. Every note, every phrase, has been carefully studied, and the music is thus presented to the listener with such clearness and finish that he cannot but admire even if unable always to approve. There is at times, it must be confessed, a slight harshness of tone and exaggeration of accent—th result, it seems to us, of the pianist's great energy and earnestness; the character of the man is reflected in his playing. He performed also Beethoven's Variations on a Russian Dance, the posthumous Rondo in G, and No. 4 from the Bagatelles (op. 126). Then followed an interesting Raff selection. Particularly would w. notice the brilliant rendering of the Prelude and Fugue from the clever Suite in E minor (op. 72 Lastly came some pieces by Rubinstein, includ ing the difficult Prelude and Fugue op. 33, No. 3, dedicated to the pianist. The audience listeni for two hours with rapt attention, and th applause was most enthusiastic. The scher of the Sonata and the Raff Fugue were both encored.

OBITUARY.

have

SIR MICHAEL COSTA, a man who in his time played many parts, died last Tuesday evening at Brighton. His career was a remarkable on His early failures as singer and composer long been forgotten; his successes as leader ani conductor, from the time when he accepted the post of maestro al piano at the King's Theatre in 1830 down to the Birmingham Festival in 1882, when he last appeared in public, will long be remembered. He ruled with a firmnay, iron-hand; but, though stern in the discharge of his duties, he was of a kindly disposition, and was not only respected, but loved, by many members of his orchestra. He was conductor at Covent Garden from 1846 to 1869, and at Her Majesty's Theatre from 1871 to 1879. In 1846 he became connected with the Philharmonic Society, and in 1848 with the Sacred Harmonic. The Birmingham Festivals from 1849 to 1882, and the Handel Festivals from 1857 to 1880, were under his manage ment; and the energy, perseverance, and great ability displayed by him have been acknowledged on all sides. A tree is known by its fruits; and history tells of the many triumphs achieved by Sir Michael Costa at these musical gatherings. His Oratorio "Eli" was produced at Birmingham in 1855, and "Naaman" in 1864.

Great men commit great faults; and, while the highest praise must be accorded to Sir Michael as a conductor, one cannot but regret that he should so frequently have tampered with the scores of the great masters. Years ago he was charged with this crime by a musician of eminence, yet he continued to pursue the same course. His inflexibility of character the cause of his greatness-proved in this matter a stumbling-block; it took the peculiar and unwelcome form of obstinacy.

MAY 10, 1884.-No. 627.]

SATURDAY, MAY 10, 1884.

No. 627, New Series.

THE EDITOR cannot undertake to return, or to correspond with the writers of, rejected manuscript.

It is particularly requested that all business letters regarding the supply of the paper, &c., may be addressed to the PUBLISHER, and

not to the EDITOR.

LITERATURE.

The Book of the Sword. By Richard F.
Burton. Vol. I. (Chatto & Windus.)
CAPT. BURTON is to be congratulated rather on
the amount than on the arrangement of his
materials. The history of the sword might
make a big book in any man's hands; in
Capt. Burton's there seems to be no reason
why it should ever end at all. This first
volume, a large one, carries us only as far as
"The Old British Sword;" for the early
Britons had swords, though Dr. Schliemann
thinks their English oppressors had none till
after the Norman Conquest. "Swords appear
to have been unknown to the Anglo-Saxons,"
writes the learned explorer of Hissarlik
(Troja, p. 96). From Capt. Burton's book
more accurate ideas about the diffusion of the
sword may be gathered, but how much else
does the author offer us that is not germane
to the matter! What have the advantages
of fox-hunting, and the cruelty of pigeon-
shooting, and the opinion of Wilkinson as
to the "Egyptian Khons," and the relations
of Samson to the Sun, and the "artistic en-
gravings of the South African Bushmen," and
the derivation of the word "glass," and the
original sense of Firbolg, to do with the
history of the sword? Capt. Burton's book
is interesting as Southey's or Buckle's com-
monplace books are interesting; it is an
omnium gatherum (as Mrs. Clive Newcome
said) of erudition, and an excellent companion
to Notes and Queries. But it is so much
more than a history of the sword that the
final history of that weapon still remains
to be written. The historian who sticks to
his subject will find Capt. Burton's book a
mine of information, but too full, we do not
say of dross, but of alien metals, precious in
their place, but out of place here.

metheus, who taught man to preserve fire in
the ferule, or stalk, of the giant fennel, was
borrowed by the Hindus and converted into
Pramantha.” Surely the hypothesis of the
etymological mythologists is that Pramantha
was corrupted into Prometheus, not that
Prometheus was twisted into Pramantha?

Next we have (still on p. 1) an examination of
the etymology of a Peruvian word, and all
this time we are being distracted from our
legitimate interest in the evolution of the
sword.

As to trace the history of the sword
is Capt. Burton's professed object, we can
only regret his love of toying with all the
Muses of all knowledge in the shade of foot-
notes. As an example of the distractions
which beguile the traveller through Capt.
Burton's tome, we select the following sen-
tence from p. 3:-

According to Capt. Hall-who, however, derived the tale from the Eskimos, the sole living representatives of the palaeolithic race in Europe the polar dear [sic], traditionally reported to throw stones, rolls down with its quasi-human forepaws rocks and boulders upon the walrus when found sleeping at the foot of some overhanging cliff.”

logical and archaeological lore connected with the topic for the consideration of his readers. He believes that the Greeks probably had no iron in "their first foreign campaign, the Trojan war." Thus the Greeks were, so far, lower than the iron-working uncivilised African races. They learned their ironworking from Egypt. Capt. Burton does not assign any particular date for the introduction of iron-working into Greece.

Chap. vii. brings us as far as the answer to the question "What is a sword?" "A metal blade intended for cutting, thrusting, or cut and thrust." It has elsewhere been pointed out that the thrust has not the advantage over the cut indicated in the drawing on p. 127. Pupils of Mr. Waite know that the cut does not require the wide action contemplated by the draughtsman. From this point Capt. Burton's book adheres much more closely to his topic, and his numerous illustrations are of particular value and interest. The fifteenthcentury "sword breakers" (fig. 134) were ingenious, but probably futile, inventions. The sword in Ancient Egypt and Modern Africa is a capital chapter, though, alas! Egyptology at large seduces the learned author, who remarks: "I need hardly say that the Capt. Burton thinks, apparently, that the mythologies of Greece, Etruria, and Rome were Eskimo are the only extant descendants of only corrupted Egyptian mysteries and metathe men who did live in Europe in palaeo-physics." This is an old, but a most improblithic times. If that is his opinion, he able, opinion, though to a certain extent it seems to have Prof. Geikie and Dr. Daniel recommended itself to Herodotus; but if one Wilson against him; but, while a reviewer "exit fighting" with Capt. Burton on Greek muses on these matters, the sword is still Mysteries, what becomes of the history of the unsheathed. One feels like the man in sword? To the point are the capital drawthe legend who blew the horn before he ings of Egyptian weapons and armour, and of drew the sword. Still, Capt. Burton does cruel Gold Coast swords, answering to Pip's draw the sword at last. He examines Theory of the Jigger in Great Expectations. the offensive weapons of animals, which may But Capt. Burton next advances to Hittite have suggested instruments to men, and keeps hieroglyphs, and I fear that he will not come, an eye on the natural weapons, stone and in my time, to the modern smallsword, for he wood, which nature offers ready made-furor returns to Troy and the war (of scholars) arma ministrat. Wooden clubs of many lands round windy Troy. Reaching Greece, Capt. are engraved, and savage and Irish wooden Burton recognises the Hesiodic and Homeric swords, with all the weapons of the boomerang knowledge of iron, while " copper was the class, are investigated. The controversy be- metal for arms and armour." But Capt. tween Gen. Pitt Rivers and Mr. Brough Smyth Burton thinks the Thracian sword of Helenus on the Egyptian boomerang seems (so far as may have been of steel. The most accurate outsiders can discern) to be ended rather in account of Homeric arms (so far as it goes) favour of Gen. Pitt Rivers. Among Capt. has been contributed by Mr. Walter Leaf to Burton's most interesting illustrations are the Journal of the Hellenic Society. The Mexican straight wooden swords edged with "Xiphos," says Capt. Burton, had a "straight picces of obsidian. The Eskimo, too, it ap- rapier blade;" the "Phasganon" was "a pears, jag the edge of wooden weapons with dirk, probably a throwing weapon, like the chips of meteoric iron. To our mind the Seax and Scrama Sax;" the "Aor" had a serrated blades of Italian daggers are not broad, stout blade; the "Machaira" hung genealogically connected with this rude device close to the sword sheath, and was for of savages. Entering on the age of metals, sacrifices and similar uses.' Though it has Capt. Burton has an interesting excursus on nothing to do with swords, one is glad copper. He prefers, generally, to translate to agree with Capt. Burton that "the Xaλkós "copper" in Homer, though the Iliad and the Odyssey might have been χαλκός weapons found at Mycenae are certainly cut in rude Phoenician letters upon wooden of bronze. Capt. Burton has had the tablets, or scratched on plates of lead." disadvantage of using Ilios as Dr. Schlie- Capt. Burton, like all swordsmen, is much mann's "last and revised volume,' ," instead interested in the singular fact that the of Troja, which, being later and more Mycenaean swords are of the type "which revised, is often at odds with Ilios. Thus became the fashion in our sixteenth century,' But what has Hermes to do with the "Great Capt. Burton thinks "the Third was the one of them being "a two-edged blade, with Unknown"? Why is he introduced here at burnt city," though Dr. Schliemann is not a midrib-in fact, the rapier, which can be all? Why are his wings explained as the any longer of that opinion. The bronze used only for the point." Then, could the expression of military metaphors? Why period is next studied by our author, who Mycenaean warriors fence? Had they the should we be led off in a note to Frederick decides that "the Proto-Phrygians and immortal passado? Alas! they used shields, the Great, and thence to Plutarch's absurd Phrygo-Europeans, of whom several tribes and were still in the age of Roderick Dhu, theory of the origin of serpent worship, returned to Asia, were the prehistoric metal not of Fitzjames, whose blade "was sword and again to the statement that "Pro-workers." Capt. Burton offers all the philo- and shield." The essay on the sword in

Capt. Burton's first page (the first, that is, of his "preamble") might give work to a dozen reviewers. We learn that "man's civilisation began with fire." This leads the author to glance at fire-myths. Prometheus is "the personification of the Great Unknown" ... who

"conceived the idea of feeding the oтéрμа Tuрòs with fuel. Thus, Hermes or Mercury was Pteropedilos or Alipes, and his ankles were fitted with pedila or talaria, winged sandals, to show that the soldier fights with his legs as

well as with his arms."

[ocr errors]
[ocr errors]
[ocr errors]

Rome is remarkable for a characteristic and amusing defence of gladiatorial shows, and an assault on that 66 meddling ecclesiastic" Telemachus.

It will be seen that Capt. Burton's book is full of interest and replete with matter; but, interested as a critic may be in mythology and swordsmanship, he prefers to keep them apart-not to read Lobeck at Mr. Waite's, or Sir William Hope in company with Kuhn.

A. LANG.

Poetry of Modern Greece: Specimens and Extracts. Translated by Florence M'Pherson. (Macmillan.)

THIS is a delightful little volume, which satisfactorily fills a vacant space in our literature. Hitherto, notwithstanding a few scattered translations, the poetry of Modern Greece has been a sealed book to most Englishmen, partly owing to the difficulties that the popular language, which is the language of poetry, presents to the scholar; and partly, perhaps, because the works themselves have found their way but little into England, and, in the case of some of the earlier poets, are difficult to procure.

were

the

The collection which is now presented to us is divided into two parts, the first of which is devoted to the ballads, the second to the works of lettered pocts. Without a notice of the ballads any account of Modern Greck literature would be imperfect, as they have flourished so richly on the soil of Greece, and are so varied in their character-comprising battle songs and others relating to the Klephts and Armatoles, or local militia, who for a time champions of Greek independence; dirges and other poems relating to the dead; love songs and imaginative pieces; farewells, to be sung by, or addressed to, members of families migrating into distant countries; and some poems which turn on historical incidents. This literature is spontaneous in its growth, and has been handed down by oral tradition among the people, the songs being usually sung at festivals and on other special occasions. The wide area over which many of them are dispersed is a proof of their popularity; and some must be of considerable antiquity, as they have been found to exist, with but slight modification, in the Greek colony which still remains in Corsica, though its founders emigrated from Greece two centuries ago and their descendants have been cut off from communication with the mother country. From the time that Fauriel first introduced this popular Greek literature to the notice of Western Europe, the process of collecting the ballads proceeded apace until in 1860 they were brought together into one volume by Arnold Passow, and critically edited, with the title Popularia Carmina Graeciae recentioris. It is from this work

selected in such a manner as to illustrate the various subjects treated of, and to represent both the wilder and the tenderer elements which they contain. The metre of the original has been followed, in some cases exactly, in others approximately; and if rimes have been introduced where they do not exist, it is difficult to find fault with that attractive embellishment. We have compared a good many of them with the Greek, and have found the translations as faithful as they are agreeable. The following, which is a fragment of a Cretan war-song, may recall to the reader some of the thoughts in Campbell's "Hallowed Ground":

-

[blocks in formation]

entire

The second part of the volume contains translations from lettered Greek poets of the present century; and these are even more welcome than the renderings of the ballads, because their authors are still less known in England, notwithstanding the great merit of some of their compositions, especially the lyrical poems. Many of those which Miss M'Pherson here presents to us deal with patriotic subjects; and foremost among these stands Solomos' famous "Ode to Liberty," of part of which a spirited version is given, the poem being too long for insertion. But the gem of this portion of the collection seems to us to be the "Lullaby" of Valaorites a most touching poem, which is beautifully translated in the varying metres of the original. It is supposed to be sung by a widowed mother, who, in her destitution, is in fear lest she should be unable to nurse her infant child. Its length prevents us from quoting it entire, and it ought not to be read piecemeal. Among living poets, Aphentoules, Paraschos, and Drosines are represented; the following poem, entitled "The Wild Vine," is by the last-named writer :

:

"The Wild Vine climbs aloft and at her side

On earth the Bramble trails his thorny stems;

O'er him the Vine her branches throws to hide

The Bramble's thorns with her white pearly

gems;

[blocks in formation]

And mated now are the unwonted pair, With my uncomeliness thy beauty rare."

In the brief remarks which are appended, that Miss M'Pherson has chiefly collected both to the ballads and to the written poems, her specimens; but she has not neglected the translator shows a laudable acquaintance other sources, for since that timo sup- with the literature of the subject, and with plementary collections have appeared, such the history and circumstances of Modern as the Cretan ballads published by Grecce. In those cases where the composiJeannaraki, and those from Epirus, by tions refer to historical subjects, the events Aravantinos; and the number is being con- referred to are described; and interesting stantly increased by those that find their way notices of the various poets and of the charinto the Athens magazines. The twenty-two acteristics of their styles are prefixed to the ballads which she has translated have been extracts from their works. Besides a fine

appreciation of what is best in the original, and an evident desire to spare no pains in reproducing it, Miss M'Pherson gives evidence of possessing some of the highest qualities requisite for her task-a sensitive feeling for rhythm, a varied and harmonious diction, and a combination of vigour and delicacy in touch. To translate some of these poems could have been no easy task, and we are glad to think that the work has fallen into such capable hands. H. F. TOZER.

THE HISTORY OF THE SCOTTISH BORDER.

The History of Liddesdale, Eskdale, Ewesdal,
Wauchopedale, and the Debateable Land.
Part I.
By Robert Bruce Armstrong.
From the Twelfth Century to 1530.
(Edinburgh: David Douglas.)

the Scottish Border and its inhabitants with a THE genius of Sir Walter Scott has surrounde halo of romance which makes it difficult to realise that until the end of the last century these picturesque dales were never mentioned by our forefathers except as a land of savages beyond the pale of civilisation. The lawless habits of the Borderers survived from the period prior to the union of the two kingdoms, when agriculture was almost unknown on the Border-side, for no man cared to cultivate fields which were constantly the scene of war, and were daily in danger of being wasted by an invading army. The Marches of Englani and Scotland were peopled by clans of mosstroopers, who lived in the intervals of war by plundering travellers and harrying cattle o the other side of the Border. These marauding clans were of too much use to their respective Sovereigns in times of war to be seriously called to account for their misdeeds but they were ruled with a strong hand by the Lord Warden of the March to which they belonged. The Wardens of the Marches of both countries were invested with great powers and privileges, which made the office covetel by nobles of the highest rank. They had their own courts for trying offenders, and maintained state almost regal in the royal castles within their jurisdiction. The chief tain of a clan occupied a tower, or peel, strong enough to resist a siege, and surrounded by a walled enclosure, called a barmkyn, into which the cattle were driven at the approach of an enemy.

ment passed in 1535 obliged "every landed man having £100 land" to build for the defence of his tenants and their cattle a barmkyn of at least sixty feet area, enclosed by a wall one ell thick and six ells high. The towers were built on strong positions within view of each other, so that on occasion of an English raid the whole country-side was apprised by signals of the approach and strength of the invaders. Strict watch and ward was ordered for the common safety to be kept hoth night and day in every Bunler tower, and the laws of the Marches required, under a heavy penalty, that beacon-fires should always be ready for lighting in case a night alarm.

An Act of the Scottish Parlia

of

The Scottish Border was, before the unien of the two Crowns, divided into three distine districts, which were called respectively the East, Middle, and West Marches. The East March comprised the sheriffdom of Berwick

Border, but those who are already interested in the subject by family associations will thank Mr. Armstrong for a useful book of EDMOND CHESTER WATERS.

granted eventually to Sir William Douglas
by Edward III., as well as by his own
Sovereign, and they remained in the posses-
sion of this powerful family until 1492, when reference.
the fifth Earl of Angus and his son exchanged
them for the barony of Bothwell.

The West March comprised the baronies of
Eskdale and Wauchopedale, as well as the
Debateable Land. The barony of Eskdale
was granted by King David to Robert Avenel,
who was a benefactor to Melrose Abbey, and
died a monk of that religious house. Four
successive generations of the Avenels were
lords of Eskdale, and were buried at Melrose;
but Sir Roger Avenel, who died in 1243, was
the last of his race, and his only daughter
carried the barony to her husband, Henry de
Graham. Their descendants still flourish at
Netherby, in Eskdale Ward, on the English
side of the Border; but Sir Richard Graham,
of Esk and Netherby, the Jacobite statesman
who was created by James II. Viscount
Preston, was a Scottish and not an English

eighteenth century the barony of a still
greater family, for it was the earliest posses-
sion in Scotland of the great house of Lindsay.
Their castle stood on a rock overhanging the
river Wauchope, half a mile from Langholm,
but it was reduced to ruins before the union
of the two Crowns. The southern extremity
of Eskdale was occupied by Canonby Priory,
which was founded in the reign of King
David by Turgot de Rossdale as a cell of
Jedburgh Abbey. The Prior of Canonby was
one of the peers of the Scottish Parliament
who in 1290 confirmed the Treaty of Salis-
bury, and later in the same year treated with
Edward I. for the marriage of his eldest son
with the Maid of Norway. The nationality
of Canonby was a constant subject of dispute,
for the English contended that it formed part
of the Debateable Land, by which it was
bounded on three sides; but it was eventually
adjudged to Scotland, and, soon after the dis-
solution of monasteries, was acquired by the
Earl of Buccleuch, to whose descendants it
has ever since belonged,

on-Tweed; but its history must be sought
elsewhere, for this volume is confined to the
early history of the Middle and West Marches,
which has been compiled by Mr. Robert Bruce
Armstrong as a labour of love, on account of
his ancestral connexion with Liddesdale and
the Debateable Land. The Armstrongs were
one of the most numerous of the Border clans,
and were so formidable in the sixteenth cen-
tury that Dr. Magnus, the English Resident,
wrote to James V. from Berwick on February
13, 1525-6 that "the Armestrongges of Lid-
dersdaill had avaunted thaymselves to be the
destruction of twoe and fifty parisshe churches
in Scotteland," and that "they woolde not be
ordoured naither by the King of Scottes, thair
soveraine lorde, nor by the King of Einglande,
but after suche maner as thaire faders had
used afore thayme." They continued to set
both Governments at defiance, until at last the
Scottish King plucked up courage to hang
without trial as outlaws John Armstrong and
his followers when he presented himself at
Court on June 8, 1530, with "24 well-peer.
horsed gentlemen of his kindred." The Wauchopedale was from the twelfth to the
peace of the Border, however, was dearly
purchased by these high-handed proceedings,
which were imputed to the King as a crime
and a blunder committed at the dictation of
the English. These gallant outlaws are in
consequence remembered by their countrymen
as patriots and martyrs, and a stirring ballad
has made their fate familiar to every peasant
on the Border-side. The execution of the
Armstrongs ranks next to the Massacre of
Glencoe among standing subjects of popular
execration. Dr. Armstrong, a well-known
poet in the last century, was a native of
Liddesdale, and a member of this same clan.
The Border counties are not mentioned in
Domesday Book, because they were not within
the dominions of the King of the English.
They formed part of the province of Cumbria,
which included the bishoprics of Carlisle,
Glasgow, and Whitherne. Carlisle and the
lands between the Duddon and the Solway
(which are now known as Cumberland) were
conquered and annexed to England by William
Rufus, but the rest of Cumbria was erected
into an earldom for David of Scotland by his
brother, King Alexander, with the consent of
King Henry I. David, before his accession
to the Scottish throne, was, in right of his
wife, Earl of Huntingdon and Northampton,
and parcelled out his Border territory in
baronies among Norman knights who held
lands under him in England. Liddesdale, the
chief barony of the Middle March, was granted
to Ranulf de Soulis, the mesne lord of Great
Doddington, in Northamptonshire. The head
of Ranulf's barony was Castleton, a fortress
which he built on the east bank of the river
Liddel, a little above its junction with the
Hermitage Water; but in later times the
lord of Liddesdale was constable of the royal
castle of Hermitage. Ranulf's descendants
were hereditary butlers of the Court of Scot-
land, and continued to hold this high office,
together with the barony of Liddesdale, until
the reign of Robert Bruce, when William de
Soulis was convicted of conspiracy against the
King's life, was stripped of his possessions,
and died a prisoner in Dumbarton Castle.
During the wars of Edward II. and Edward
III. Liddesdale and Hermitage Castle were in
the hands of the English; but they were

The Debateable Land comprised the parish of Kirkandrews with one half of Morton and the greater part of Bryntallow, which were left undivided when the frontier was settled in the reign of Robert Bruce. It was separated from Cumberland by the river Esk from its junction with the Liddel until it poured its waters into the Solway Firth, and the fishgarths which prevented salmon from ascending the stream were resented as a standing grievance by the inhabitants of Eskdale. Partition was made of the Debateable Land in 1552; but, as every reader of Redgauntlet will remember, the fish-garths continued to be the cause of violence and contention long after the union of the two kingdoms.

Mr. Armstrong has collected from the public records a detailed history of the Scottish Border from 1495 to 1530, and has supplemented his text by a valuable Appendix of proofs and authorities. It is inconvenient enough that the Index is reserved for the next volume, but it is unaccountable that the Table of Contents should not include a list of the documents printed as proofs. A more stirring and spirited narrative would have created a new interest in the eventful history of the

Practical Essays.
(Longmans.)
LIKE many other writers, Dr. Bain has had
some difficulty in selecting an appropriate
title for a collection of miscellaneous articles
reprinted from periodicals. He cannot be
congratulated on the choice he has made, as
the contents of several of these essays by no
means correspond to the anticipations which
the title of the volume will naturally suggest.
The first two papers, indeed ("Common
Errors on the Mind" and "Errors of Sup-
pressed Correlatives"), would not have been
out of place if the collective title of the
essays had designated them as "Speculative
instead of "Practical.”

By Alexander Bain.

[ocr errors]

Readers who are acquainted with the valuable work which Dr. Bain has done in the field of psychological research will turn to these two essays with keen interest. It is to be feared, however, that their expectations will be disappointed. Although these essays contain some excellent observations, they do not, on the whole, rise above an ordinary level, and the paradoxes with which the author has attempted to relieve their dulness are neither brilliant nor true. Dr. Bain is laudably desirous that his readers should "clear their minds of cant" in relation to moral questions. But it seems to me that his recoil from certain ethical commonplaces has landed him in some positions which are more radically mistaken than the most extreme forms of the doctrines against which he protests.

Dr. Bain is resolved to give no quarter to what he considers the foolishly sentimental talk about "virtue being its own reward." The maxim that happiness is most surely attained by not making it the chief object of endeavour, he treats as though its only element of truth lay in the fact that excessive self-scrutiny is prejudicial to enjoyment. There is no doubt that the propositions which Dr. Bain impugns have often been exaggerated into absurdity. It is not true that the intrinsic pleasure involved in right action always outweighs in amount its attendant pains. Nor is it true that pleasures deliberately sought can contribute little or nothing to the happiness of a life. But it is true that, in minds animated by a genuine love of goodness, the thought of a right action is the source of a satisfaction which is not dependent on any personal consequences to the agent; and it is a fact of every-day experience that the happiest persons are, very often at least, those whose absorbing interest in outward objects leaves them little leisure to think of pleasure for its own sake. Dr. Bain's hostility to any association of virtue with pleasure is so extreme that he actually asserts that "benevolence in itself is painful; any virtue is pain in the first instance, although when equally responded to it brings a surplus of pleasure." The author is so delighted with this discovery that he repeats it several times in nearly identical terms. Now there would be a certain degree of truth in Dr. Bain's contention, if it related to beneficent actions done purely from a sense of duty; but to

« PreviousContinue »